Late Night Things to Do Near Setauket and Mount Sinai
If you live in Setauket, East Setauket, Mount Sinai or Miller Place, you already know the deal. These are great places to live, with parks, beaches and quiet streets, and that also means not much is open after 9pm. When you want to get out of the house late, you end up in the car anyway.
The good news is that Port Jefferson sits right between the Three Village area and Mount Sinai, so the village is never far. We run Roots Kava Bar on East Main Street, and plenty of our late-night regulars drive in from these towns. Here's what's open and worth doing once it gets late.
Before it gets dark: close to home
A couple of spots worth knowing for an early evening, before you head into the village.
Frank Melville Memorial Park, East Setauket. A 24-acre park around the Melville Mill Pond, privately run and open to the public. There's a walking trail, an arboretum kept up by the Three Village Garden Club, a mill house with a working simulated mill wheel, and a barn from the early 1700s. It's one of the prettiest walks on the North Shore, and a good start to an evening.
Cedar Beach, Mount Sinai. A town beach on the peninsula between Mount Sinai Harbor and Long Island Sound. The west end has a fishing pier and a marina, and there's a nature preserve behind the beachfront with a paved walkway. On a clear evening the view across toward Port Jefferson is worth the drive. Check the Town of Brookhaven's rules for evening hours and parking.
Both of these are evening spots, not midnight spots. For the later part of the night, head into Port Jefferson.
Late night in Port Jefferson
Roots Kava Bar, 250 East Main Street. We're open until 11pm Sunday through Thursday and until 1am Friday and Saturday, which makes us one of the latest non-bar options in the area. There's no alcohol in the building. We pour coffee, espresso, ceremonial-grade matcha, herbal tea, house mocktails and kava served in a shell, and we have vegan snacks. There are board games and video games on the shelf, couches in the lounge, and live music.
Kava is a traditional Pacific island drink made from a root and water. It tastes earthy and a little peppery, it's drunk in one or two gulps, and for a lot of people it's a relaxing, social way to end the day without a drink. If it's not for you, we have plenty of other things on the menu.
Friday comedy and open mic. Every Friday at Roots. Sign-ups at 7:30pm, open mic at 8pm, professional Long Island comedians at 9pm, suggested donation at the door. It's an easy Friday plan if you don't want to deal with a crowded bar. Full details on our comedy night page.
Late coffee and matcha. Most cafes around here close by mid-afternoon. If you want a latte at 10pm, we wrote about that in coffee open late in Port Jefferson and matcha in Port Jefferson.
A night walk at the harbor. The Port Jefferson waterfront is free and open, and walking it late with the ferry tied up and the lights on the water is one of the simplest good things to do around here. Some routes are in our night walk post.
Movies, bowling and a show
PJ Cinemas. A seven-screen first-run movie theater at 1068 Route 112 in Port Jefferson Station, just south of Route 347. A late movie, then a coffee in the village, is an easy weeknight.
Port Jeff Bowl. A bowling alley at 31 Chereb Lane in Port Jefferson Station. Call (631) 473-3300 for lane times.
Theatre Three. A nonprofit professional theater at 412 Main Street in Port Jefferson, running since 1969. An evening show lets out right around the time you'd want a late drink, and Roots is a short walk up the hill.
Plans that work
The weeknight wind-down (Setauket). Walk Frank Melville Park in the early evening, then drive over to Roots for a matcha or a shell and a board game before 11pm.
The Friday night (Mount Sinai). Sunset at Cedar Beach, dinner in Port Jefferson, then the open mic at 8pm and pro comedy at 9pm at Roots.
The Saturday late night. A movie at PJ Cinemas, then Roots until 1am, then a walk down to the harbor.
The group night. Birthday, team night or a friend group that doesn't drink? We host private parties for up to about 40 with no minimum and no deposit. For more ideas, see alcohol-free nightlife on Long Island.
Getting to Roots: 250 East Main Street, Port Jefferson, NY 11777, up the hill from the harbor and a short walk from the ferry. Open 12pm to 11pm Sunday through Thursday and 12pm to 1am Friday and Saturday, happy hour 4pm to 7pm daily. Directions on our visit page, or call (934) 259-8902.
Late night FAQ
What's open late near Setauket?
Roots Kava Bar in neighboring Port Jefferson is open until 11pm Sunday through Thursday and 1am Friday and Saturday, with coffee, matcha, mocktails and kava.
What is there to do at night near Mount Sinai?
Head into Port Jefferson for Friday comedy at Roots, a late coffee or kava, a harbor walk, a movie at PJ Cinemas or bowling at Port Jeff Bowl.
Is there a place to hang out late without drinking near Port Jefferson?
Yes. Roots Kava Bar is fully alcohol-free and has board games, video games, live music and couches.
Where can I get coffee at night near Setauket or Mount Sinai?
Roots Kava Bar on East Main Street in Port Jefferson serves coffee and espresso until 11pm on weeknights and 1am on Fridays and Saturdays.

Product Title
16 px collapsible text is perfect for longer content like paragraphs and descriptions. It’s a great way to give people more information while keeping your layout clean. Link your text to anything, including an external website or a different page. You can set your text box to expand and collapse when people click, so they can read more or less info.
$320

Product Title
16 px collapsible text is perfect for longer content like paragraphs and descriptions. It’s a great way to give people more information while keeping your layout clean. Link your text to anything, including an external website or a different page. You can set your text box to expand and collapse when people click, so they can read more or less info.
$900

Product Title
16 px collapsible text is perfect for longer content like paragraphs and descriptions. It’s a great way to give people more information while keeping your layout clean. Link your text to anything, including an external website or a different page. You can set your text box to expand and collapse when people click, so they can read more or less info.
$560


Comments