Comedy Shows on Long Island This Fall: Where to Laugh Without a Bar Tab
Updated: 5 days ago
Once the beach days are over, Long Island moves indoors, and comedy is one of the best ways to spend a fall night. You get a real show, you laugh for two hours, and nobody has to plan anything after.
The catch at a lot of comedy clubs is the bill. Ticket, then an item or drink minimum, then the drinks themselves, and a $20 night turns into $60 fast. We run Roots Kava Bar in Port Jefferson, where comedy happens every Friday in an alcohol-free room with a suggested donation at the door. Here's our guide to comedy on Long Island this fall, including the big clubs, so you can pick what fits.
Friday Night Comedy Night and Open Mic at Roots
250 East Main Street, Port Jefferson. Every Friday.
7:30pm: Sign-ups for the open mic
8:00pm: Open mic. Music, poetry, creative writing and stand-up are all welcome, first timers included
9:00pm: Professional Long Island comedians take the stage
Cost: Suggested donation at the door, which goes toward creating and running performing arts programs
The room seats about 40, so it feels like a real show without being a crowd. Because there's no alcohol in the building, the audience is there to listen. Nobody heckles from six drinks deep, and comics notice the difference. Order coffee, matcha, a house mocktail or a shell of kava, the earthy, peppery Pacific island root drink we're named for, or just sit and watch. Full details are on our comedy night page, and if you want to try a set yourself, read how open mic nights work on Long Island.
Friday, Oct 30: Halloween comedy at Roots. Our Halloween edition lands on a Friday this year. The Healing Circle for Women presents the All Female Cast Costume Party and Halloween Comedy Show at 8:30pm. Entry is $5 with a 1 drink minimum, and since everything we pour is alcohol-free, that drink can be a matcha, a mocktail or a shell. Come in costume. The lineup is on our comedy night page.
If you're looking for a Halloween night out on Long Island that isn't a packed bar, this is it.
The big Long Island comedy clubs
These are the established clubs, all part of the same family, and they book national headliners as well as local comics. Check each club's site for this fall's lineup.
Governor's Comedy Club, Levittown. At 90 Division Avenue, Governor's opened in 1985 and is one of the best known comedy clubs on Long Island. Besides the main room, it has a smaller room called The Giggle Room and an outdoor stage, The Patio, used mostly in warmer months.
McGuire's Comedy Club, Bohemia. A sister club of Governor's in Bohemia, which makes it the closest of the big clubs for most of Suffolk. It hosts headliners, local shows and fundraiser nights.
The Brokerage Comedy Club, Bellmore. Also part of the Governor's family. The Brokerage opened in 1980, making it one of the oldest comedy clubs on Long Island.
A note on cost: comedy clubs commonly have an item or drink minimum on top of the ticket. That's normal, just budget for it.
Improv at Theatre Three
Theatre Three, 412 Main Street, Port Jefferson. Theatre Three has long hosted Friday Night Face Off, billed as Long Island's longest running improv comedy show. Two teams compete using audience suggestions, in the style of "Whose Line Is It Anyway?" Past shows ran late on Friday nights, around 10:30pm. Check Theatre Three's site to see whether it's running this fall before you plan around it.
If it is running, that makes for a great Port Jefferson double feature: open mic and pro comedy at Roots from 8pm, then improv down the hill.
Plan a comedy night out
For a date: Comedy is a strong date move because nobody has to carry the conversation. See our ideas for a date night in Port Jefferson without drinking.
For a group: A Friday show is easy for a birthday or a friend group. If you want the room for your own night, we host private parties for up to about 40, with no minimum and no deposit.
For performers: Get to Roots by 7:30pm on a Friday to get on the list.
After the show: Roots stays open until 1am on Fridays and Saturdays, so you can hang around for coffee, a game off the shelf or another round. The full list is on our menu.
Getting here: Roots Kava Bar is at 250 East Main Street, Port Jefferson, NY 11777, up the hill from the harbor and a short walk from the ferry. Open 12pm to 11pm Sunday through Thursday and 12pm to 1am Friday and Saturday, happy hour 4pm to 7pm daily. Directions on our visit page, or call (934) 259-8902.
Comedy on Long Island FAQ
Where can I see comedy on Long Island on a Friday?
Roots Kava Bar in Port Jefferson runs an open mic at 8pm and pro Long Island comedians at 9pm every Friday. The big clubs, Governor's in Levittown and McGuire's in Bohemia, also run weekend shows.
Is there a comedy show on Long Island for Halloween 2026?
Yes. On Friday, Oct 30, Roots Kava Bar hosts the All Female Cast Costume Party and Halloween Comedy Show at 8:30pm, $5 entry with a 1 drink minimum.
Is there alcohol-free comedy on Long Island?
Yes. The Friday comedy night at Roots Kava Bar is in a fully alcohol-free room, with a suggested donation at the door.
How much does the Roots comedy night cost?
There's a suggested donation at the door. Special shows like the Oct 30 Halloween show have their own ticket price.

Product Title
16 px collapsible text is perfect for longer content like paragraphs and descriptions. It’s a great way to give people more information while keeping your layout clean. Link your text to anything, including an external website or a different page. You can set your text box to expand and collapse when people click, so they can read more or less info.
$320

Product Title
16 px collapsible text is perfect for longer content like paragraphs and descriptions. It’s a great way to give people more information while keeping your layout clean. Link your text to anything, including an external website or a different page. You can set your text box to expand and collapse when people click, so they can read more or less info.
$900

Product Title
16 px collapsible text is perfect for longer content like paragraphs and descriptions. It’s a great way to give people more information while keeping your layout clean. Link your text to anything, including an external website or a different page. You can set your text box to expand and collapse when people click, so they can read more or less info.
$560


Comments